XPS vs EPS Insulation: Which Rigid Foam Is Right? (2026)

Labeled XPS is R-5.0/inch at 75°F (ASTM C578 minimum), above EPS at R-3.6–4.4/inch depending on type. [1][2][3] XPS also has lower moisture absorption than EPS. EPS costs less and has no blowing-agent aging, so its day-one R-value does not decline from gas diffusion. As wall sheathing at R-5 in an existing home, NREL's REMDB 2024 prices EPS at $1.00–$2.03 per sq ft (median $1.26) and XPS at $1.21–$4.38 per sq ft (median $1.50) installed (2023 dollars). [4] Use XPS for below-grade and high-moisture applications. Use EPS for budget projects, SIPs, and where cost drives the decision.

Updated November 18, 2026
16 min read

R-value by board thickness

  • 1-inch XPSR-5.0
  • 1-inch EPSR-3.6–4.4
  • 2-inch XPSR-10.0
  • 2-inch EPSR-7.2–8.8
  • 3-inch XPSR-15.0
  • 3-inch EPSR-10.8–13.2
Labeled R-values at 75°F from the cited table on this page. Bar colors follow R per inch: cooler means more.

XPS and EPS are both polystyrene foam boards made from the same base polymer by different manufacturing processes. XPS (extruded) has a higher labeled R-value and lower moisture absorption. EPS (expanded) costs less, holds its day-one R-value without blowing-agent aging, and uses an air-filled cell structure. The right choice depends on moisture exposure, budget, and whether you are planning for short-term or long-term performance.

Table of Contents


Master Comparison Table

R-value and compressive-strength figures below are from ASTM C578 and manufacturer data sheets; the installed cost is NREL REMDB 2024 (2023 dollars, national). [1][2][3] [4]

PropertyXPS (Extruded Polystyrene)EPS (Expanded Polystyrene)
R-Value/InchR-5.0 (at 75°F, ASTM C578 min)R-3.6–R-4.4 (varies by type)
R-Value (1" board)R-5.0R-3.6–R-4.4
R-Value (2" board)R-10.0R-7.2–R-8.8
Temperature StabilityR increases as mean temperature fallsR increases as mean temperature falls
Moisture AbsorptionLower than EPS by lab test; both take up water below grade over yearsHigher than XPS by lab test; both take up water below grade over years
Vapor Permeability~1.2 perm/inch (Class II)~2.6 perm/inch (Class III)
Compressive Strength15–100 psi (Types X/IV/VI/VII/V)10–60 psi (Types I/II/IX/XIV/XV)
Long-Term R-ValueDisputed; current FOAMULAR NGX LTTR is R-5.0/inch, legacy XPS lowerNo blowing-agent aging; below-grade moisture lowers R
Blowing AgentHFC-134a (legacy) or current HFC-134a-free / HFC-compliant formulationsAir (pentane used in manufacturing, replaced by air)
Environmental (GWP)Legacy HFC-134a GWP 1,430; current low-GWP blendsNo retained fluorocarbon blowing agent
ColorPink (Owens Corning Foamular) or Blue (DuPont, formerly Dow)White
Installed cost, wall sheathing at R-5 (existing home)$1.21–$4.38 per sq ft (median $1.50)$1.00–$2.03 per sq ft (median $1.26)
Best ForBelow-grade, foundations, high moistureSIPs, budget ci, cost-driven projects
XPS vs EPS Foam Board Compared: R-value, vapor permeability, strength and best uses. Table image from insulationrvalues.com.
XPS vs EPS Foam Board Compared, drawn from the cited table on this page. Open it full size to save or share it.

For how XPS and EPS compare against polyiso (the third rigid foam type), check the full rigid foam insulation guide.


R-Value Comparison

Labeled XPS at R-5.0/inch is higher per inch than EPS by an amount that depends on the EPS type. Against DOE BASC typical EPS (3.8–4.4/inch) the gain is about +14% to +32%; against ASTM C578 EPS minimums (3.6 for Type I to 4.3 for Type XV) it is about +16% to +39%. The table below uses the 3.6–4.4/inch range shown elsewhere on this page. [1][2][3]

ThicknessXPS R-ValueEPS R-ValueXPS Advantage
1"R-5.0R-3.6–4.4+14% to +39%
2"R-10.0R-7.2–8.8+14% to +39%
3"R-15.0R-10.8–13.2+14% to +39%

At 2 inches, XPS gives R-10 where EPS gives roughly R-8. In the errata-corrected 2021 IECC, Table R402.1.3 lets wood-frame walls in climate zones 4–8 comply with R-30 cavity alone, or with R-20 cavity plus R-5 continuous insulation, or R-13 cavity plus R-10ci, or R-0 cavity plus R-20ci. Continuous insulation is one compliance path, not a blanket requirement, and R-5 ci applies only when paired with an R-20 cavity. One inch of XPS delivers R-5.0; one inch of EPS at R-3.6–4.4 falls short of R-5, so it takes about 1.1 to 1.4 inches of EPS (in practice a 1.5-inch board) to reach R-5. The 2024 IECC sets its own wall values; confirm the current adopted edition and table for your jurisdiction. [5][6]

How this compares over the long term is disputed and covered below: current FOAMULAR NGX publishes an LTTR of R-5.0/inch, while legacy XPS generations aged lower.

Winner on day-one R-value: XPS.


Moisture Resistance

Lower moisture absorption is the main technical reason to choose XPS over EPS.

XPS takes up less water than EPS in standard lab tests. Its closed-cell, extruded structure resists water entry at the surface. The short-duration immersion tests behind these claims do not describe years of below-grade service, though.

EPS takes up more water than XPS. Its expanded-bead structure has gaps between beads that can wick moisture over time, and absorbed water lowers the measured R-value.

Long-term field data shifts the picture for both. Samples pulled from below-grade service after 15 to 31 years held far more water than a lab immersion test suggests: Owens Corning's University of Alaska embankment samples held 2.1–9.1% water by volume for XPS after 31 years and 4.7–21.5% for EPS after 21 years; the EPS Molders Association's 15-year side-by-side test in St. Paul found the reverse, 18.9% for XPS against 4.8% for EPS. Each study was funded by one side. An embankment is a harsher condition than a drained foundation wall. [7][8]

Practical context: In practice EPS performs acceptably below grade when drainage (dimple mat, gravel, perimeter drain) directs bulk water away from the board. Many ICF (insulated concrete form) foundations use EPS as the core material. Treat either foam as insulation that tolerates some moisture, not as waterproofing.

For below-grade applications where drainage is less reliable or soil moisture is high, XPS's lower lab absorption provides a wider margin.

Winner: XPS — lower moisture uptake. This is a deciding factor for below-grade and high-moisture applications.

Pro Tip: When using EPS below grade, add a dimple mat or drainage board between the soil and the foam. This directs bulk water away from the EPS surface and limits how much water reaches it. With proper drainage, EPS works in most residential foundation applications, and NREL's REMDB 2024 prices it about 14% to 20% below XPS installed at the same R-value. [4]


Cost Comparison

NREL's Residential Efficiency Measures Database (REMDB 2024) prices rigid foam installed, per square foot of surface at a given R-value, in 2023 dollars, national. [4]

Installed cost (REMDB 2024, existing home)XPSEPS
Wall sheathing at R-5, per sq ft [4]$1.21–$4.38 per sq ft (median $1.50)$1.00–$2.03 per sq ft (median $1.26)
Wall sheathing at R-10, per sq ft$1.83–$5.52 per sq ft (median $2.38)$1.34–$3.49 per sq ft (median $1.91)
Unfinished basement wall at R-10, 1,000 sq ft$1,828–$5,518 (median $2,381)$1,344–$3,486 (median $1,912)

Source: NREL REMDB 2024 unit costs (times the area for the basement row), 10th to 90th percentile with the median in parentheses. [4]

At the same R-value, REMDB's EPS median runs about 14% to 20% below XPS, as wall sheathing and on basement walls alike. [4] Because REMDB prices by R-value, the thicker EPS board needed for the same R-value is already in its price. REMDB gives no board-foot or material-only price, so this page gives none.

Winner: EPS — about 14% to 20% less installed at the same R-value (NREL REMDB 2024).


Temperature Stability

Both XPS and EPS gain R-value as the mean temperature falls, which is the opposite of what polyiso does in the cold.

EPS R-value rises as it gets colder. Atlas ThermalStar Type I measures 3.9 → 4.2 → 4.4 R/inch and Type II measures 4.2 → 4.6 → 4.8 R/inch at mean temperatures of 75 / 40 / 25°F, a gain of about 8–14%; Insulfoam R-Tech Type I runs 3.85 → 4.17 → 4.35 over the same range. At 25°F, Type II EPS near R-4.8/inch outperforms polyiso, which the NRCA roof-board data put at about R-4.05/inch at 25°F. There is no registry data for EPS at 0°F, so no claim is made there. [9][10][11]

XPS also improves slightly in the cold, about +8% at 40°F and +12% at 25°F versus its R-5.0/inch at 75°F. The blowing agent in the cells conducts less heat as it cools, which raises the measured R-value. [2][12]

For climate zones 5–8 where exterior insulation faces sustained cold, both XPS and EPS hold or gain R-value, while polyiso loses R-value as the mean temperature drops.

Winner in the cold: EPS and XPS both gain R-value, and at a 25°F mean both beat polyiso (at 40°F polyiso's R-4.91 still tops EPS). [11] [9]


Long-Term R-Value: The Aging Factor

How XPS ages depends on the product generation, and the evidence is disputed and trade-funded on all sides.

XPS long-term R-value by generation:

XPS generationLong-term R-value/inchSource
Legacy HCFC-22~R-4.5–4.65 (about 7–10% below the 180-day value)ORNL review
HCFC-142b era (lab-measured)~R-4.74/inch averageIIBEC paper (author works for a polyiso maker)
Current FOAMULAR NGXR-5.0/inch (LTTR)Owens Corning data sheet

The decline in older XPS happened because the fluorocarbon blowing agent in the closed cells slowly diffused out and was replaced by air, which conducts more heat. ASTM C578 R-values are 180-day aged values; XPS LTTR is determined under CAN/ULC-S770, as stated on the FOAMULAR NGX data sheet. Current FOAMULAR NGX publishes an LTTR of R-5.0/inch and warrants at least 90% retention, and DuPont states its Styrofoam board holds R-5 per inch long term. [13][2][14]

EPS has no blowing-agent aging, but below-grade moisture lowers its R. EPS is blown with pentane during manufacturing, and the pentane dissipates during and shortly after production, leaving an air-filled cell structure with no fluorocarbon gas to diffuse out. There is no gas-aging derate. Water uptake below grade does cut performance, though: the EPS Molders Association's 15-year St. Paul test found EPS at 94% of its specified R at 4.8% water by volume, and Owens Corning's University of Alaska embankment samples measured R-1.74–3.36/inch after 21 years at 4.7–21.5% water. An embankment is harsher than a drained foundation wall. [8][7]

Winner depends on the data you trust. Current XPS and EPS both publish stable long-term R-values; below-grade moisture is the main driver of in-service loss for either foam.


Environmental Impact

EPS retains no fluorocarbon blowing agent in the finished board.

EPS manufacturing uses pentane as a blowing agent, which dissipates during production and leaves an air-filled cell structure. No fluorocarbon blowing agent remains in the finished board. The registry has no EPS pentane GWP figure, so no number is given here.

XPS historically used HFC-134a (GWP 1,430), which Alberta Infrastructure's materials table reports from an earlier industry source. Current US XPS data sheets list lower-GWP formulations: Kingspan GreenGuard GG25-LG is free of HFC-134a with a blend GWP under 50, and DuPont describes its Styrofoam board as a U.S. HFC Regulation Compliant Formulation. [15][16][14]

No source on file compares how widely the two foams are recycled, so this page does not rank them on recycling.

Winner: EPS — no retained fluorocarbon blowing agent.

Pro Tip: When a project prioritizes environmental impact (green building certification, LEED points, or personal values), EPS keeps no fluorocarbon blowing agent in the finished board. Its lower R per inch (R-3.6–4.4 against XPS at R-5.0) is made up with a slightly thicker board, and at the same R-value NREL's REMDB 2024 still prices it below XPS. [4]


Compressive Strength

Both foams are made in a range of compressive-strength grades. The table below lists the ASTM C578 minimum compressive strengths by type rather than slab loads; the slab designer or manufacturer guidance sets the required grade for a given application. [1][2][9][17]

ASTM C578 minimumXPS typeEPS type
10 psi—Type I
15 psiType XType II
25 psiType IV (e.g. Foamular 250)Type IX
40 psiType VI (e.g. Foamular 400)Type XIV
60 psiType VII (e.g. Foamular 600)Type XV
100 psiType V (e.g. Foamular 1000)—

XPS grades run from 15 psi (Type X) to 100 psi (Type V). EPS grades run from 10 psi (Type I) to 60 psi (Type XV); Type XIV (40 psi) and Type XV (60 psi) are standard C578 EPS types and are made, for example Atlas ThermalStar boards. The 60 and 100 psi XPS grades (Foamular 600 and 1000) cover the heaviest loads, where no standard EPS type is rated.

Winner: XPS — its 100 psi grade covers loads above the EPS maximum of 60 psi.


Applications: Which Foam Where

ApplicationRecommendedWhy
Below-grade foundation wallsXPS preferredLower moisture uptake in lab tests; both foams still take up water over years below grade
Below-grade foundation (with drainage)EitherEPS works with proper drainage and costs less installed at the same R-value (NREL REMDB 2024) [4]
Under-slab (residential)EitherPick the grade from the slab load; XPS for the heaviest loads
Under-slab (commercial/heavy)XPSHigher compressive strength options (up to 100 psi)
Exterior wall ciEither (EPS more cost-effective)Both perform well above-grade. EPS saves money on large wall areas.
SIPs (structural insulated panels)EPSIndustry standard core material for residential SIPs
ICFs (insulated concrete forms)EPSStandard ICF core material — proven over decades
EIFS (exterior insulation finish systems)EPSStandard substrate for EIFS applications
Re-siding projectsEither (EPS for budget)Above-grade application — cost often drives the decision

For how XPS and EPS fit into full wall and foundation assemblies, the wall insulation guide and basement insulation guide cover the complete picture.


Choose XPS When / Choose EPS When

How to choose, by application:

Choose XPS When:

  • Below-grade without reliable drainage: XPS's lower moisture uptake provides the wider safety margin
  • High compressive loads: XPS offers products up to 100 psi for commercial and heavy-duty applications
  • Maximum R-value in minimum thickness: R-5.0/inch vs R-3.6–4.4 means fewer inches needed
  • Direct soil contact for extended periods: lower lab uptake gives a margin, though both foams take up water over decades below grade

Choose EPS When:

  • Budget is a priority: about 14% to 20% less than XPS installed at the same R-value (NREL REMDB 2024) [4]
  • No blowing-agent aging: EPS has no gas-aging derate; below-grade moisture is the main cause of in-service R-value loss
  • Environmental priority: no retained fluorocarbon blowing agent
  • SIPs, ICFs, or EIFS applications: EPS is the industry standard for all three
  • Above-grade continuous insulation: moisture absorption is less of a concern above grade; EPS delivers solid value
  • Below-grade with proper drainage: EPS performs well with dimple mat and perimeter drains at a lower installed cost

Key Takeaways

  • Labeled XPS is R-5.0/inch at 75°F; EPS is R-3.6–4.4/inch by type. XPS is about 14% to 39% higher on day-one R-value.
  • Current FOAMULAR NGX publishes an LTTR of R-5.0/inch; legacy XPS aged lower. EPS has no blowing-agent aging, though below-grade moisture lowers its R.
  • XPS takes up less water than EPS in lab tests. Both foams absorb water over years below grade, so this is a margin, not a guarantee.
  • At the same R-value, NREL's REMDB 2024 prices EPS about 14% to 20% below XPS installed (2023 dollars). [4]
  • EPS keeps no fluorocarbon blowing agent in the finished board; current XPS sheets list HFC-134a-free or HFC-compliant formulations.
  • Both XPS and EPS gain R-value as the mean temperature falls, and at a 25°F mean both outperform polyiso.
  • For below-grade with good drainage, EPS is the better value. For below-grade without reliable drainage, XPS provides the wider moisture margin.
  • Neither foam can be left exposed in occupied spaces. Foam plastic must be separated from the living space by an approved thermal barrier such as 1/2-in. gypsum wallboard unless the product's evaluation report allows otherwise (IBC 2021 Sec. 2603.4; IRC R316.4). Check the product's ICC-ES report and your local code. [18][19]

FAQ

Does XPS lose R-value over time?

It depends on the product generation. Legacy XPS lost roughly 7–10% of its R-value long term as the fluorocarbon blowing agent in the closed cells diffused out and was replaced by air. The figures are disputed and trade-funded on all sides. Current FOAMULAR NGX publishes an LTTR of R-5.0/inch and warrants at least 90% retention. ASTM C578 R-values are 180-day aged values; XPS LTTR is determined under CAN/ULC-S770, not under ASTM C578. EPS has no gas-aging derate because its cells are already air-filled. [13][2]

Can I use EPS below grade?

Yes, with proper drainage. EPS takes up more water than XPS, but in practice it performs acceptably below grade when a dimple mat or drainage board directs bulk water away from the foam surface. Many ICF foundations and basement retrofits use EPS. Pair EPS with adequate drainage and do not rely on it as a moisture barrier. For high water tables or poorly drained clay soils, XPS provides a wider safety margin.

Which is better for the environment — XPS or EPS?

EPS keeps no fluorocarbon blowing agent in the finished board. It is made with pentane that dissipates during production, leaving an air-filled cell structure. XPS historically used HFC-134a (GWP 1,430); current US XPS data sheets list lower-GWP formulations, such as Kingspan GreenGuard GG25-LG with a blend GWP under 50 and DuPont's HFC-compliant Styrofoam board. For projects that weigh blowing agents, EPS keeps none in the finished board. [16][14]

Is XPS worth the higher price?

It depends on the application. For below-grade foundation walls in wet soil without reliable drainage, XPS's lower moisture uptake justifies the premium. For above-grade continuous wall insulation or any application where moisture exposure is minimal, EPS delivers good value: at the same R-value NREL's REMDB 2024 prices it about 14% to 20% below XPS installed. [4] The R-per-inch advantage of XPS (about 14% to 39%, depending on the EPS type) can be offset by using slightly thicker EPS boards.

Sources

  1. Owens Corning Foam Insulation, LLC, FOAMULAR & FOAMULAR NGX XPS Insulation: ASTM C578 Types and Physical Properties (Tech Bulletin, Pub. No. 10015702-C, July 2025) reproducing ASTM C578-23 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  2. Owens Corning Foam Insulation, LLC, Product Data Sheet FOAMULAR NGX 250 XPS Insulation, Pub. No. 43522-V, Oct 2025 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  3. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory / US DOE Building America Solution Center, Typical R-values and Vapor Retarder Classifications for Common Insulation Materials — Building America Solution Center (PNNL for US DOE), updated 2021-12-23 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  4. National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), National Residential Efficiency Measures Database (REMDB) 2024 — machine-readable file REMDB_2024.12.23.xlsx (CC BY 4.0) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  5. International Code Council (ICC), 2021 IECC Errata (complete) - Table R402.1.3 entry, Printings: All, posted 2021-08-10 updated 2026-09-18 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  6. US DOE Building America Solution Center (PNNL), DOE/PNNL Building America Solution Center: '2009-2021 IECC and IRC Minimum Insulation Requirements for New Homes' (updated 2021-09-17) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  7. Owens Corning Foam Insulation, LLC (reporting University of Alaska / Billy Connor data), Comparison of Polystyrene Expanded and Extruded Foam Insulation in Roadway and Airport Embankments — University of Alaska Case Study Tech Bulletin, Pub. No. 10024736, May 2021 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  8. EPS Industry Alliance (then EPS Molders Association), EPS Below Grade Series 103: 15-Year In-Situ Research Shows EPS Outperforms XPS in R-Value Retention (technical bulletin, 2008) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  9. Atlas Molded Products (division of Atlas Roofing Corp.), ThermalStar E Tech Data sheet (ARC-064 TS E Tech-Data_10.25) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  10. Insulfoam (a Carlisle company), R-Tech I 10 psi Moisture Resistant Insulation technical data sheet (TDS dated 04/30/18) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  11. National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA), Professional Roofing, Tech Today, Mark S. Graham, Professional Roofing, March 2015 ('NRCA tests reveal polyisocyanurate R-values are lower than product manufacturers' published long-term thermal resistance values') (retrieved Nov 2026)
  12. Owens Corning Foam Insulation, LLC, Capturing the Thermal Performance of FOAMULAR NGX XPS vs. Polyisocyanurate, Tech Bulletin Pub. No. 10019949-B, July 2026 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  13. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (T. Stovall), Closed Cell Foam Insulation: A Review of Long Term Thermal Performance Research, ORNL/TM-2012/583, Nov 2012 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  14. DuPont (Performance Building Solutions), Styrofoam Brand Square Edge Extruded Polystyrene Foam Insulation product page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  15. Government of Alberta, Infrastructure Technical Services Branch, Design & Technology Series 06: Understanding Insulation — Considerations for PERSIST Assemblies (c. 2016) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  16. Kingspan Insulation LLC, Kingspan GreenGuard GG25-LG XPS Insulation Board product data sheet, v3, 03/2026 (retrieved Nov 2026)
  17. Atlas Molded Products (division of Atlas Roofing Corp.), ThermalStar X Tech Data sheet (ARC-064 TS X Tech-Data_10.25) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  18. City of Seattle SDCI (reproduction of ICC 2021 IBC), 2021 Seattle Building Code, Chapter 26 Plastic (retrieved Oct 2026)
  19. Vermont Office of Economic Opportunity (Weatherization Assistance Program), WAP Technical Policies & Procedures Manual (2026 Edition), Appendix P: Thermal & Ignition Barriers (PDF pp. 173-175) (retrieved Nov 2026)