Fiberglass vs Cellulose Insulation: Which Is Better for Your Home? (2026)

For attic floors, blown-in cellulose gives more R per inch (R-3.2–3.8 vs R-2.5–3.0), so it needs less depth. For wall retrofits, dense-pack cellulose fills closed cavities through small holes and cuts air leakage through them, as dense-packed fiberglass can. Fiberglass wins on settling resistance (about 1% vs about 10% for loose-fill cellulose) and noncombustibility. Both are good options; the best choice depends on your specific application.

Updated November 18, 2026
12 min read

Attic depth, inches

  • R-49 cellulose14"
  • R-49 blown fiberglass16.4–18.25"
  • R-60 cellulose17"
  • R-60 blown fiberglass19.75–21.75"
Depth for R-49 and R-60 from the cited table on this page (cellulose at settled depth). Cellulose has more R per inch, so its bars are cooler and shorter.

Fiberglass and cellulose are the two fibers you can blow into an attic or a closed wall. Blown in, NREL's REMDB 2024 prices them on the same installed line, so the decision rests on performance, not budget. [1] The real differences show up in R-value per inch, settling behavior, air sealing capability, and fire safety.

Table of Contents


Master Comparison Table

PropertyFiberglass (Batts)Fiberglass (Blown-In)Cellulose (Loose-Fill)Cellulose (Dense-Pack)
R-Value/InchR-3.0–R-3.7 (standard)R-2.5–R-3.0R-3.2–R-3.8R-3.6–R-3.8
Installed cost, attic floor at R-49 (REMDB 2024, existing home, per sq ft) [1]$2.71–$5.11 per sq ft (median $3.37)$1.02–$2.13 per sq ft (median $1.83) (one loose-fill line for both fibers)Same line as blown fiberglassNo REMDB price (too little data for dense pack)
Fire (FSI / SDI)≤25 / ≤50 (unfaced, non-combustible)Non-combustible (ASTM E136)Class A (treated)Class A (treated)
MoistureTraps moisture, loses R when wetSameHygroscopic (absorbs/releases)Same
SettlingNone (batts), ≈1% (blown)≈1%~10% (loose-fill)Minimal at 3.0–3.5 lb/ft³
Air SealingNoneNoneMinimalSignificant
DIY-FriendlyBatts: easy. Blown: moderateModerateModerateProfessional only
Recycled ContentRecycled glassSameRecycled newspaperSame
Pest ResistanceNoneNoneBorate deters pestsSame

Air sealing: [2]. Cellulose fire rating: [3]. Source for R-value and fire figures: [4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12]. Installed cost: [1].

Fiberglass vs Cellulose Compared: R-value per inch, settling, air sealing and moisture, batts to dense pack. Table image from insulationrvalues.com.
Fiberglass vs Cellulose Compared, drawn from the cited table on this page. Open it full size to save or share it.

For complete guides on each material: fiberglass insulation and cellulose insulation.


R-Value Comparison

Cellulose delivers more R-value per inch than blown-in fiberglass, which translates to meaningfully less depth required in attic applications.

MaterialR-Value/InchDepth for R-49Depth for R-60
Blown-in celluloseR-3.2–3.8 (settled)~14" (settled)~17" (settled)
Blown-in fiberglassR-2.5–3.0~16.4–18.25"~19.75–21.75"
Standard fiberglass battsR-3.0–3.7~14" (single HD batt) or ~16" (stacked standard)Impractical (19"+, two stacked layers)

Source: [4][5][6][7][8][9][13][14][15][11][16][17]. The per-inch figure for cellulose applies at settled thickness.

Cellulose achieves R-49 in approximately 14 inches of settled depth. Blown fiberglass needs about 16.4–18.25 inches. [5][7][8][9][13][11] In attics with limited headroom at the eaves, that difference matters.

Fiberglass batts have a higher R-per-inch (R-3.0–3.7) than blown-in fiberglass. But batts have a different problem: installation quality. A poorly fitted batt installation (gaps, compression around wiring, voids at edges) measurably cuts real-world performance. ORNL hot-box tests of an R-19 wall measured R-15.4 for a careful installation and R-13.2 for a "worst typical" one with rounded shoulders and small voids, about a 14% loss. [18][19][20] Blown-in fill flows around obstructions, though it still has to reach the chart depth to deliver its rating.

Winner: Cellulose — higher R-per-inch than blown fiberglass. The R-value per inch chart ranks every insulation type.


Cost Comparison

NREL's Residential Efficiency Measures Database (REMDB 2024) prices installed insulation by form and place, not by fiber: one line for all blown loose fill, cellulose or fiberglass, and one for all batts, in 2023 dollars, national, 10th to 90th percentile with the median in parentheses. [1] So for blown-in attic work it shows no price difference between the two fibers, and the choice rests on performance.

1,000 sq ft Attic Floor, Existing Home (REMDB 2024)

Installed toBlown loose fill (cellulose or fiberglass)Fiberglass batts
R-30 [1]$719–$1,737 (median $1,213)$2,110–$4,120 (median $2,555)
R-38$844–$1,903 (median $1,471)$2,363–$4,536 (median $2,899)
R-49$1,017–$2,131 (median $1,825)$2,712–$5,108 (median $3,372)

At each level the loose-fill median is about half the batt median. REMDB's loose-fill fit stops at R-49, so it gives no R-60 price. [1] Both fibers can be installed DIY with a rented blowing machine; REMDB prices installed work only.

Detailed pricing at blown-in insulation cost and the insulation cost calculator.

Winner: Tie. REMDB prices blown cellulose and fiberglass on one line, and on an attic floor that loose fill costs about half what batts do. Choose on performance.


Settling

This is cellulose's most-discussed weakness, and it's real but manageable.

Blown-in cellulose settles about 10% as it reaches its rated density. Manufacturer coverage charts already build this in: filling to the chart's initial installed depth (about 15.0–16.1 inches for R-49) leaves roughly 13.5–14.5 inches settled, which is where the labelled R-value is rated (FTC 16 CFR 460.5). [13][15][21][17] If your installer follows the chart and you verify depth before they leave, settling is already handled.

Blown-in fiberglass settles about 1% or less. Glass fibers are springy and hold their loft. The installed depth is essentially the final depth, with no over-fill needed. [8][22][5][7]

Dense-pack cellulose in walls barely settles. Dense-pack density is set as the minimum that prevents settling, per the Cellulose Insulation Manufacturers Association; Nu-Wool specifies 3.0–3.5 lb/ft³ and PNNL's Building America guidance 3.5–4.5. [23][11][24]

Settling is a valid concern, not a dealbreaker. Install cellulose to the initial depth on the manufacturer's chart and it hits its target R-value after settling. If the thought of settling bothers you, blown fiberglass stays essentially at its installed depth.

Winner: Fiberglass — about 1% settling vs about 10% is a clear advantage in long-term depth retention.

Pro Tip: Measure cellulose depth in 6–8 locations across the attic before the installer leaves. Installed depth should match the initial installed thickness on the bag chart, about 11% above the settled target for dry loose-fill. If it falls short, ask them to add more material on the spot while the machine is still set up. [13][17][25]


Air Sealing

Dense-pack cellulose cuts air leakage through a wall cavity; Building Science Corporation notes that dense-packed fiberglass can do the same. [2]

In BSC's lab tests, empty wall cavities leaked 0.4–4 cfm/ft² at 0.3 in. w.c. and dense-packed ones 0.04–0.2, about a tenth as much. [2] It is not an air barrier by code definition, but it is a significant practical improvement.

Loose-fill cellulose in attics (at 1.5 lb/ft³) provides minimal air sealing. [26][13][15] Blown-in fiberglass (at comparable attic densities) provides none. For attic applications, air sealing the floor before insulating is essential regardless of which material you use: air sealing and insulating together save an average of about 15% on heating and cooling costs (about 11% of a typical home's total energy bill), per ENERGY STAR. [27][28][29]

Winner: Dense-pack, of either fiber. Attic loose fill of either kind is no substitute for air sealing.


Fire Safety

Both materials carry Class A fire ratings, but the underlying performance is different.

Fiberglass is non-combustible. It's spun glass; it does not ignite or sustain flame. Unfaced blankets carry a Flame Spread Index ≤25 and Smoke Development Index ≤50 (ASTM E84), and are non-combustible under ASTM E136. This performance is inherent to the material, with no treatment needed. [12][7]

Cellulose is treated-combustible. It's recycled newspaper, highly flammable without treatment. Borate fire retardants give it a Class A rating: Greenfiber's SANCTUARY lists a flame spread index of 25 or less and smoke-developed index of 50 or less (UL). [3]

For fire-critical applications (garage walls, mineral wool for fire-rated assemblies), fiberglass or mineral wool (FSI 0, SDI 0) are safer choices. [30]

Winner: Fiberglass — inherently non-combustible, with no treatment to rely on. For maximum fire safety, mineral wool is better than both.


Moisture Behavior

Fiberglass doesn't absorb water chemically, but it traps moisture in the air spaces between fibers. When wet, it insulates less until it dries. It won't support mold growth itself (inorganic glass), but trapped moisture promotes mold on adjacent organic materials (wood framing, paper-faced drywall).

Cellulose is hygroscopic. It actively absorbs and releases moisture from the air. In moderate amounts, this can be an advantage: cellulose acts as a moisture buffer in wall assemblies, absorbing excess humidity during damp periods and releasing it when conditions dry out. The risk: prolonged saturation causes cellulose to clump, sag, and potentially promote mold.

Neither material is suitable for perpetually wet locations (crawl spaces, below-grade). For those, closed-cell spray foam or mineral wool are better choices.

Winner: Slight edge to fiberglass, which regains its R-value once it dries. Neither handles persistent moisture well.


Environmental Impact

Cellulose is made from recycled paper, and fiberglass from glass that can include recycled glass. No source on file compares their manufacturing energy, emissions or end-of-life fate, so this page does not rank them on environmental impact.


Wall Retrofits: Dense-Pack

For insulating existing walls without removing drywall, both fibers come in dense-pack form.

Dense-pack cellulose is blown through access holes at 3.0–3.5 lb/ft³ density, filling every gap in the cavity including around wiring, plumbing, and fire stops. Nu-Wool and SANCTUARY both chart it at R-13 in a 2×4 wall. [15][31] NREL's REMDB 2024 rates its data for loose fill in stud walls low on sample size and fit, so this page gives no installed price for dense pack. [1]

Dense-pack fiberglass products such as Johns Manville Spider Plus (1.5–1.8 lb/ft³) and Knauf Jet Stream ULTRA (1.8 lb/ft³) chart about R-4.0–4.3 per inch in wall cavities, and BSC notes that dense-packed fiberglass can cut air leakage as cellulose does. [7] [8] [2]

For wall retrofit details, see insulating walls without removing drywall for the complete process.

Winner: Either, dense-packed. Ask installers which fiber and density they use.


Choose Fiberglass When / Choose Cellulose When

Choose Fiberglass When:

  • Non-combustibility is required: fiberglass won't burn; cellulose relies on treatment
  • Minimal settling is important: about 1% vs about 10% for loose-fill cellulose
  • Wet-prone areas: fiberglass regains its R-value once it dries
  • New construction walls with skilled installers: fiberglass batts at Grade I installation perform well; NREL's REMDB 2024 prices batts in a stud wall at R-13 at $1.16–$2.80 per sq ft (median $1.37) installed [1]

Choose Cellulose When:

  • Attic blow-in: better R-per-inch (less depth needed)
  • Wall retrofit (drill-and-fill): dense-pack cellulose fills closed cavities through small holes
  • Recycled content matters to you: cellulose is made from recycled paper
  • Air sealing matters: dense-pack meaningfully reduces air movement through wall cavities
  • Irregular cavities with many obstructions: cellulose conforms better than batts

Pro Tip: You don't have to choose just one. Cellulose works well in the attic (less depth) and fiberglass batts in new-construction walls (cost-effective in open cavities with good installers). Use the right material for each application.


Key Takeaways

  • For attic blow-in, cellulose has a slight performance edge: R-3.2–3.8/inch vs R-2.5–3.0 (blown fiberglass), so it needs less depth.
  • For wall retrofits, dense-pack cellulose or dense-pack fiberglass fills closed cavities and cuts air leakage through them. [2]
  • Fiberglass settles about 1% vs cellulose's about 10% in attics. Both are manageable; cellulose is installed about 11% above its settled target per the bag chart.
  • Fiberglass is inherently non-combustible (SDI ≤50 for unfaced blankets); cellulose relies on borate treatment.
  • Cellulose uses recycled newspaper and has high recycled content.
  • NREL's REMDB 2024 prices all blown loose fill on one line, cellulose or fiberglass, so price does not separate them; on attic floors that line runs about half the batt median at the same R-value. Choose on performance. [1]
  • Neither material provides true air sealing in attic applications; always air seal the attic floor first.

FAQ

Which is better for attic insulation — fiberglass or cellulose?

For blown-in attic floors, cellulose has a slight edge: higher R-per-inch means less depth (14" vs ~16.4–18.25" for R-49), and NREL's REMDB 2024 prices both fibers on the same loose-fill line. [1] Blown fiberglass settles less (about 1% vs about 10%) and is non-combustible. Both are solid choices: the performance difference is smaller than the benefit of doing the project at all. If you want the most R-value in the least depth, choose cellulose. If minimal settling and non-combustibility matter more, choose fiberglass.

Does cellulose insulation settle?

Yes. Dry loose-fill cellulose settles about 10% as it reaches its rated density, and manufacturer coverage charts already build this in. Fill to the chart's initial installed depth (about 15.0–16.1 inches for an R-49 settled depth of about 13.5–14.5 inches). Because the labelled R-value is rated at settled density (FTC 16 CFR 460.5), an attic filled to the chart does not lose R-value below its target. Dense-pack cellulose in walls settles much less because the higher density resists compression. [13][15][21][17]

Can I blow cellulose over existing fiberglass?

Yes. R-values are additive. Blow cellulose directly over existing fiberglass. Old batts with kraft facing laid paper-down against the ceiling can stay as they are: loose fill adds no second facing, so nothing gets trapped between layers. Verify the existing insulation is dry and free of mold or pest damage first. The R-value chart shows target values by climate zone.

Is fiberglass or cellulose safer?

Fiberglass is inherently non-combustible but causes skin, eye, and respiratory irritation during installation (wear an N95 mask, gloves, and long sleeves). Cellulose is borate-treated and safe in normal conditions, but it's technically combustible: the borate treatment is what prevents ignition. Both materials are considered safe for residential use when properly installed. For fire safety, fiberglass has a better inherent profile. Complete safety info at is fiberglass safe? and mineral wool insulation.

Sources

  1. National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), National Residential Efficiency Measures Database (REMDB) 2024 — machine-readable file REMDB_2024.12.23.xlsx (CC BY 4.0) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  2. Building Science Corporation (Joseph Lstiburek), BSI-043: Don't Be Dense - Cellulose and Dense-Pack Insulation (2010-12-13) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  3. UL Solutions (copy hosted by Greenfiber), UL Evaluation Report ER15890-01 (holder Applegate Greenfiber; SANCTUARY, FRM, SANCTUARY DEFENSE), revised 2025-05-28 (retrieved Nov 2026)
  4. Owens Corning, PINK Next Gen Fiberglas Insulation Manufacturers Fact Sheet (Pub. 10025109-B, May 2026) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  5. Owens Corning, ProPink L77 PINK Fiberglas Loosefill Insulation Manufacturers Fact Sheet (Pub. 22676-O, Dec 2023) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  6. Johns Manville, Fiberglass Manufacturers Fact Sheet (BID-380, 12/19, (c)2019) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  7. Johns Manville, JM Building Insulation Submittal Form (BID-0028, 9/26) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  8. Knauf Insulation, Knauf Jet Stream ULTRA Blowing Insulation Product Data Sheet (valid from 05/25; (c)2024), linked from knaufnorthamerica.com product page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  9. CertainTeed, CertainTeed InsulSafe SP Fiberglass Blowing Insulation data sheet (Code No. 09-11-4525-US-EN, 10/24) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  10. City of Seattle SDCI (adopts WA State Energy Code App. A), 2021 Seattle Energy Code, Appendix A (Default Heat Loss Coefficients), Table A101.4 R-value of fiberglass batts compressed within various depth cavities (retrieved Oct 2026)
  11. Nu-Wool Co., Inc., Nu-Wool Premium Cellulose Insulation product page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  12. NAIMA, Insulation Facts #8: ASTM Standard Specifications for Mineral Fiber Blanket, Loose-Fill and Spray-Applied Insulation (BI 455, 11/04) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  13. Applegate Insulation (Greenfiber), Applegate Loose-fill Cellulose Insulation Fact Sheet (#IFS-ALF26.5-201606-A, (c)2020; RDS-LF9587), archived copy (Wayback Machine 2023-05-25) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  14. Applegate Insulation (Greenfiber), Applegate Stabilized Cellulose Insulation Fact Sheet (PM 6.3330 Rev A 09/24, Greenfiber) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  15. Nu-Wool Co., Inc., Nu-Wool 'This Is Cellulose' FTC fact sheet / Pneumatic Application Coverage Chart (05/2016) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  16. Cellulose Insulation Manufacturers Association (CIMA), How To Calculate R-Value Of Settled Cellulose Attic Insulation (Aug 16 2022, mod. Sep 30 2022) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  17. US Federal Trade Commission (16 CFR 460), 16 CFR Part 460 Labeling and Advertising of Home Insulation (FTC R-value Rule), via Cornell LII e-CFR mirror - § 460.5 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  18. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Christian, Kosny, Desjarlais, Childs), The Whole Wall Thermal Performance Calculator — On the Net, Thermal Envelopes VII (1998) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  19. US Navy Civil Engineering Laboratory (contract N68305-77C-0009; work by Johns-Manville R&D Center, D. Verschoor), Effectiveness of Building Insulation Applications (Nov 1977), DTIC ADA053452 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  20. BRANZ (New Zealand building research levy-funded institute), Poorly fitted wall insulation cuts thermal performance, BUILD 117 (Apr/May 2010), I. Cox-Smith (retrieved Oct 2026)
  21. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Wilkes & Childs), Thermal Performance of Fiberglass and Cellulose Attic Insulations, ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings V (Dec 1992) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  22. NAIMA, Questions and Answers About Home Insulation (BI409, 3/00) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  23. Cellulose Insulation Manufacturers Association (CIMA), Technical Bulletin: Standard Practices for Installation of Cellulose Insulation in the United States (Feb 2023) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  24. U.S. DOE Building America Solution Center (PNNL), Dense-Pack Insulation (REDCalc tool page, undated) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  25. US Federal Trade Commission (16 CFR 460), 16 CFR Part 460 Labeling and Advertising of Home Insulation (FTC R-value Rule), via Cornell LII e-CFR mirror - § 460.12 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  26. Greenfiber, Greenfiber SANCTUARY Defense Attic Card (PM-6.3328-SD Rev C, 03/25) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  27. US EPA ENERGY STAR, ENERGY STAR 'Why Seal and Insulate?' (retrieved Oct 2026)
  28. US EPA ENERGY STAR, ENERGY STAR 'Methodology for Estimated Energy Savings' (retrieved Oct 2026)
  29. U.S. EPA ENERGY STAR, ENERGY STAR Seal and Insulate page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  30. ROCKWOOL, ROCKWOOL Comfortbatt Thermal Batt Insulation Technical Data Sheet (US), issued 07-2026 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  31. Greenfiber, SANCTUARY Cellulose Fact Sheet (PM-6.3329 Rev K, 05/26) (retrieved Nov 2026)