7 Types of Home Insulation: Comparison Guide (2026)

The seven main types of home insulation are fiberglass, cellulose, mineral wool, spray foam (open-cell and closed-cell), rigid foam board (EPS, XPS, polyiso), radiant barriers, and natural/eco materials. Closed-cell spray foam gives the highest R-value per inch, R-6.0 to R-7.0, [1] [2] but in NREL's national cost database spray foam costs about three times as much as batts at R-13 in a stud wall, and on an open attic floor blown-in loose fill is the cheapest option. [3] The best type depends on where you're insulating, your climate zone, your budget, and whether you need fire resistance, moisture control, or soundproofing.

Updated November 19, 2026
28 min read

R-value per inch

  • Closed-cell spray foamR-6.0 – R-7.0
  • Rigid foam boardR-3.6 – R-6.5
  • Mineral woolR-3.7 – R-4.3
  • Wool, denim, corkR-3.5 – R-4.0
  • Fiberglass battR-3.0 – R-4.3
  • Open-cell spray foamR-3.5 – R-3.8
  • CelluloseR-3.2 – R-3.8
Labeled R-value per inch at the FTC test temperature, from the cited table on this page. Bar colors follow the thermal scan: cooler means more R per inch.

Table of Contents


Master Comparison Table

TypeR-Value/InchFlame Spread (FSI)Moisture Resistant?Sound (NRC)DIY-Friendly?Best Application
Fiberglass BattR-3.0 – R-4.3≤25No — absorbs waterGoodYesWalls, attic floors (new construction)
Cellulose (loose/dense)R-3.2 – R-3.8See product E84 dataNo — absorbs, but dries wellGoodPartial (loose-fill yes)Attic floors, wall retrofits
Mineral WoolR-3.7 – R-4.30Yes — water repellent per ROCKWOOLHighYesFire-rated assemblies, soundproofing, exterior walls
Open-Cell Spray FoamR-3.5 – R-3.8See product ESRNo — absorbs moistureFairNoAttic rooflines, cathedral ceilings
Closed-Cell Spray FoamR-6.0 – R-7.0See product ESRYes — Class II vapor retarder at about 1.5–2 in. or moreFairNoBasements, crawl spaces, limited-depth cavities
Rigid Foam Board (EPS/XPS/Polyiso)R-3.6 – R-6.5See product ESRYes (XPS, EPS)LowPartialContinuous exterior insulation, below-grade
Radiant BarrierN/A (reflects radiant heat)See product dataYesNoneYesAttic roof decks in hot climates (CZ 1–2, especially with attic ducts)
Natural (wool, denim, cork)R-3.5 – R-4.0VariesVariesGoodYesEco-conscious projects, specialty applications

Installed costs are in the cost comparison below. R-value figures come from each material's primary source: manufacturer data sheets and ICC-ES evaluation reports for spray foam, ASTM C578 and manufacturer data for rigid board, and PNNL's Building America Solution Center typical-value table. Mineral wool's flame-spread and smoke-developed index of 0 (ASTM E84) and the closed-cell vapor-retarder class are from the sources cited in the sections below; ROCKWOOL describes its stone wool as water repellent. See our R-value insulation chart for complete R-value data and insulation cost calculator for project pricing. [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [1] [2] [9] [10]

Types of Insulation Compared: R-value per inch, moisture resistance and DIY-friendliness by type. Table image from insulationrvalues.com.
Types of Insulation Compared, drawn from the cited table on this page. Open it full size to save or share it.

1. Fiberglass Insulation

Fiberglass comes in two forms: batts (pre-cut blankets) and blown-in (loose-fill).

Batts are manufactured in standard widths (15" for 16" OC framing, 23" for 24" OC) and come in specific R-values matched to cavity depths. Common products include R-11 and R-13 (3.5" thick for 2×4 walls), R-15 high-density (also 3.5"), R-19 (a 6.25" batt), R-21 high-density (5.5" for 2×6), and R-30/R-38/R-49 for attics and floors. A 6.25" R-19 batt is sized for a 6.25" cavity; compressed into a 5.5" 2×6 cavity it delivers about R-18 (Owens Corning rates the 6.25" batt at R-18 when it fills 5.5", and the Seattle/WSEC code table lists R-18). To reach a full R-19 or more in a 2×6 you need a 5.5" product such as R-20, R-21, or R-23. Faced batts have a kraft paper or foil vapor retarder on one side; unfaced batts don't. [11] [12] [13] [14] [15]

Blown-in fiberglass is machine-blown into attics and wall cavities. In attic applications, it delivers about R-2.5 to R-3.0 per inch at 75°F, rising with depth as it is installed thicker. At about 16.4–18.25 inches (installed = settled), blown-in fiberglass reaches R-49, per manufacturer minimum-thickness charts. [16] [17] [18] [19]

Pros: Batts are the lowest-cost way to fill an open stud wall in NREL's national cost database, ahead of spray foam and foam board at the same R-value. [3] Widely available. Noncombustible (won't burn, though it can soften and melt at high temperature). DIY-friendly in batt form. Won't rot or support mold growth.

Cons: Very sensitive to installation quality — gaps, compression, and voids are the #1 performance killer. In hot-box tests, ORNL (1998) measured a 2×6, 24-in. o.c. wall with R-19 batts at R-15.4 for a perfect installation and R-13.2 (a 14% drop) for a "worst typical" installation with rounded batt shoulders, small voids, and inset stapling; a 1977 Johns-Manville study for the U.S. Navy found a 4.2% uninsulated area cut an R-19 ceiling's resistance by 34%. Doesn't air seal. Absorbs and holds moisture, losing significant R-value when wet. Susceptible to wind washing in exposed locations. Batts are essentially useless around irregular obstructions (wiring, plumbing, electrical boxes) unless carefully cut and fitted. [20] [21] [22]

Cost: batts at R-13 in an open stud wall, $1.16–$2.80 per sq ft (median $1.37) installed in new construction; blown-in loose fill at R-49 on an attic floor, $1.02–$2.13 per sq ft (median $1.83) in an existing home. NREL REMDB 2024, 2023 dollars, national, 10th to 90th percentile. [3]

For the complete breakdown, see our fiberglass insulation guide.


2. Cellulose Insulation

Cellulose is made from recycled newspaper treated with borate fire retardants. It comes in two forms: loose-fill (blown into open attics) and dense-pack (blown under pressure into enclosed cavities).

Loose-fill cellulose at R-3.2 to R-3.8 per inch (rated at settled density) flows around obstructions better than batts, which typically means better coverage around wiring, plumbing, and ductwork. [23] [24] [25] NREL's REMDB 2024 prices it in one line with blown-in fiberglass: loose fill has the lowest median installed cost of any insulation it prices for attic floors. [3]

Dense-pack cellulose at about R-3.6 to R-3.8 per inch is a common way to insulate existing walls without opening them. An installer drills access holes through the siding or interior plaster, inserts a fill tube, and blows cellulose under pressure until the cavity is completely packed. The high density resists settling and provides modest air-sealing properties — not a full air barrier, but meaningfully better than batts. The target density varies by source: Nu-Wool packs walls to 3.0 to 3.5 lb/cu ft, while the Building America guidance from PNNL recommends 3.5 to 4.5. [26] [27] [24] [28]

Pros: High recycled newspaper content. Excellent coverage around obstructions. Dense-pack provides good air-sealing properties. Borate treatment resists fire, mold, and pests.

Cons: Loose-fill settles about 10% from the installed depth, but manufacturer coverage charts already build this in, and labelled R-values are rated at settled density — so an attic filled to the chart's initial installed depth does not fall below its label. Follow the bag chart's initial installed depth (about 11% above the settled target for dry loose-fill). Absorbs moisture (though borate treatment helps it resist mold). Heavier than fiberglass, so it can cause ceiling sag if over-applied on older drywall without adequate support. Requires blowing machine (DIY possible for attic loose-fill, but dense-pack needs professional equipment and training). Borate-treated for fire resistance; check the product's ASTM E84 results for its flame-spread and smoke-developed figures. [29] [30]

Cost: loose fill at R-49 on an attic floor, $1.02–$2.13 per sq ft (median $1.83) installed in an existing home (NREL REMDB 2024, 2023 dollars, national; one line for cellulose and fiberglass). REMDB publishes no wall price for dense-pack: it rates that data low on both sample size and fit. [3]

Full guide: cellulose insulation. Compare head-to-head: fiberglass vs. cellulose.


3. Mineral Wool / Rockwool

Mineral wool (often sold under the brand name Rockwool) is made from basalt rock and recycled slag spun into fibers. It delivers R-3.7 to R-4.3 per inch; ROCKWOOL's ComfortBatt data sheet publishes a thickness per R-value (R-15 at 3.5", R-23 at 5.5", R-30 at 7.25"), which works out to about R-4.0–4.3 per inch. It's available as batts, rigid boards (Comfortboard), and loose-fill. [9] [31] [17]

Mineral wool is the material to consider when a project needs fire resistance, sound control, or moisture management beyond what fiberglass offers.

Fire performance is mineral wool's headline advantage. ROCKWOOL's ComfortBatt data sheet reports a flame-spread index of 0 and a smoke-developed index of 0 (ASTM E84) and classes the product as noncombustible (ASTM E136), which is why mineral wool is a frequent choice for fire-rated wall and floor assemblies. See our insulation fire safety guide for the full comparison. [9]

Sound performance is another strength. ROCKWOOL rates its 3-inch Safe'n'Sound batt at a noise reduction coefficient (NRC) of 1.10 (ASTM C423), [32] which makes it a common pick for soundproofing between shared walls, floors, or around home theaters.

Moisture handling rounds out the case. ROCKWOOL describes its stone wool as water repellent and says water does not affect its R-value. [10] That makes it a good fit for exterior applications and areas prone to occasional moisture.

Pros: Noncombustible (ASTM E136). Strong sound absorber. Water repellent, per ROCKWOOL. Denser and more rigid than fiberglass, so it holds its shape in cavities without sagging. Higher R-per-inch than standard fiberglass. DIY-friendly.

Cons: Stiffer and denser, which makes it harder to cut and fit around obstructions. Heavier to work with. More limited product availability in some regions.

Cost: NREL's REMDB 2024 prices mineral wool and fiberglass batts as one line: at R-15 in an open stud wall, $1.22–$2.90 per sq ft (median $1.45) installed in new construction (2023 dollars, national). [3] It has no separate mineral wool price, so get a quote for the product you want.

Full guide: mineral wool insulation. Compare: fiberglass vs. mineral wool.


4. Spray Foam Insulation

Spray foam is a two-component liquid that expands on contact and cures into a solid foam. It comes in two types with very different properties, costs, and applications.

Open-Cell Spray Foam

Open-cell foam expands on contact to fill cavities completely. It delivers R-3.5 to R-3.8 per inch (similar to cellulose). (R-value per inch varies with thickness, per FTC 16 CFR 460.20.) [6] [7] [8] [33]

It creates an air barrier while insulating. Open-cell foam is soft and flexible, so it is forgiving on wood framing that expands and contracts. It is most often used on attic rooflines (underside of the roof deck) to create a conditioned attic, and in cathedral ceilings where access for blown-in materials is limited.

The downside: open-cell foam absorbs moisture. It is vapor-permeable (about 23 perms at 1 in., 9 perms at 2 in., and under 10 perms at 3.5 in. or more), so at typical roofline thickness it behaves as a Class III vapor retarder (greater than 1 to 10 perms). It allows moisture to pass through, which is a feature in some assemblies and a liability in others. It must not be used below grade or in perpetually wet locations. See our open-cell spray foam guide for vapor management details. [34] [35] [36]

Closed-Cell Spray Foam

Closed-cell foam is denser, stronger, and delivers R-6.0 to R-7.0 per inch — the highest of any common insulation material. (R-value per inch varies with thickness, per FTC 16 CFR 460.20.) At about 1.5–2 inches or more, it acts as both an air barrier and a Class II vapor retarder (under 1.0 perm). [1] [2] [4] [37]

Closed-cell spray foam also adds some structural rigidity to the assembly. It is a good fit for basements (directly on concrete walls), crawl spaces, rim joists, and any application where you need maximum R-value in minimum depth. In a 2×4 wall, 3.5 inches of closed-cell foam delivers about R-22 to R-26 (per ICC-ES evaluation reports) — roughly double what fiberglass provides in the same space. [38] [1] [2] [6]

The downsides: at R-13 in a stud wall, closed-cell spray foam costs about three times what batts cost, and on an open attic floor loose fill reaches the same R-value for a fraction of the price. [3] It uses hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) or hydrofluoroolefin (HFO) blowing agents — older HFC formulations have high global warming potential, though newer HFO-blown products are much better. Installation requires certified professionals with specialized equipment.

Cost: at R-13 in an open stud wall in new construction, open-cell $2.28–$6.11 per sq ft (median $3.98) and closed-cell $3.09–$9.14 per sq ft (median $4.48); on an attic roof deck in an existing home, open-cell at R-21 $4.09–$11.32 per sq ft (median $7.31) and closed-cell at R-29 $7.80–$23.04 per sq ft (median $11.26). NREL REMDB 2024, 2023 dollars, national. [3]

Full guides: spray foam insulation, open-cell vs. closed-cell comparison, spray foam cost guide.


5. Rigid Foam Board Insulation

Rigid foam boards are manufactured in 4×8 foot sheets (and other sizes) across a range of thicknesses: polyiso runs ½ to 4.5 inches, XPS from ½ inch sheathing up through 3 inches, and EPS boards up to 7.25 inches for walls (14.25 inches for ceilings under ICC-ES ESR-5261). Three types dominate the market: [39] [40] [5] [41]

EPS (Expanded Polystyrene) — R-3.6 to R-4.4 per inch, and it gains R-value as it gets colder. Of the three boards it has the lowest median installed cost as R-5 wall sheathing in NREL's REMDB 2024. [3] It's widely used for ICFs (insulated concrete forms), EIFS (exterior insulation finish systems), and below-grade applications. EPS absorbs some moisture over time, so it's usually used with drainage considerations in below-grade installations. EPS guide. [42] [43] [4]

XPS (Extruded Polystyrene) — R-5.0 per inch at 75°F (the ASTM C578 label value: 1 in. = R-5, 2 in. = R-10). Recognizable by its blue (DuPont, formerly Dow), pink (Owens Corning), or green (Kingspan) color. XPS is the standard for below-grade and high-moisture applications because of its low moisture absorption. It performs slightly better in cold temperatures. Legacy HCFC-blown XPS aged to about R-4.5–4.65/in; current products such as FOAMULAR NGX publish an LTTR (CAN/ULC S770) of R-5.0/in with at least 90% retention, and DuPont states a long-term value of R-5 per inch. Higher environmental impact than EPS due to blowing agents. XPS guide. [5] [44] [45]

Polyisocyanurate (Polyiso) — R-5.6 to R-6.5 per inch (at 75°F). The highest R-per-inch of any rigid foam and the go-to for exterior continuous insulation on walls and commercial roofing. The critical caveat is cold-temperature derating. NRCA's 2014 tests (published in Professional Roofing, March 2015) measured 2-in. polyiso roof boards at R-5.56/in at 75°F, R-4.91/in at 40°F (a 12% drop), and R-4.05/in at 25°F (a 27% drop); at a 25°F mean, polyiso performs near R-4.0/in. In cold climates (CZ 5–8), derate by about 15–25% or layer with EPS/XPS. Polyiso guide. [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51]

Common applications for all rigid foam types: Continuous exterior insulation over wall sheathing (to reduce thermal bridging), basement and foundation walls, under-slab insulation, cathedral ceiling insulation above the roof deck, and as insulating sheathing in new construction.

Cost: as wall sheathing in new construction, EPS at R-5 $0.93–$1.96 per sq ft (median $1.19), XPS at R-5 $1.14–$4.31 per sq ft (median $1.43) and polyiso at R-6 $1.11–$1.95 per sq ft (median $1.51), installed (NREL REMDB 2024, 2023 dollars, national). [3]

Full guide: rigid foam board insulation.


6. Radiant Barriers

Radiant barriers are fundamentally different from the insulation types above. A radiant barrier has no R-value rating on its own. Instead, it reflects radiant heat, primarily from the sun heating your roof. Under the FTC rule, reflective insulation is rated from its emittance (ASTM E408/C1371) combined with the specific air space and heat-flow direction (ASHRAE Handbook Chapter 26), not from the ASTM C518 method used for bulk insulation, and labels must state the number of sheets, air spaces, and the resulting R-value. [52] [25]

A radiant barrier is a reflective material (usually aluminum foil laminated to kraft paper, OSB, or plastic) installed in the attic, typically on the underside of the roof rafters. With an emittance of 0.1 or less (ASTM C1313), it reflects at least 90% of the radiant heat that would otherwise radiate from the hot roof deck down into the attic insulation; ORNL's savings figures are based on clean foil at 0.05 or less, about 95%. [53] [54]

Where they work: Hot, sunny climates — primarily climate zones 1 and 2 (the Deep South, Southwest, Florida, Hawaii), especially where ducts run through the attic. FSEC research puts the saving at 8–12% of annual cooling costs in the Southeast, a range DOE's Building America program repeats for hot climates. [55] [56]

Where they don't work: Cold and marine climates. Radiant barriers address heat gain from solar radiation. In CZ 5 and up, the heating season dominates your energy bill, and radiant barriers provide negligible benefit during heating months. Your money is better spent on more insulation or air sealing.

Limitations: A radiant barrier does nothing for conductive or convective heat loss. It's a supplement to insulation, not a replacement. Any vendor claiming a radiant barrier replaces conventional insulation is misleading you. Dust accumulation on the reflective surface reduces performance over time.

Cost: $0.67–$1.50 per sq ft (median $1.23) installed, from NREL's REMDB 2024 in 2023 dollars. REMDB gives radiant barriers one flat price with no regression behind it and a low sample size. [3]


7. Natural & Eco-Friendly Insulation

A growing niche of insulation products caters to homeowners prioritizing sustainability, indoor air quality, or specific environmental certifications.

Sheep's wool has natural moisture-buffering properties. Havelock's sheep's wool batts are rated R-14 at 3.5 in. and R-22 at 5.5 in. (test method not stated by the maker). It's naturally fire-resistant and provides decent sound absorption. [57]

Recycled cotton/denim batts are made from post-industrial recycled cotton and polyester, treated with borate for fire and pest resistance. UltraTouch denim batts are rated R-13 at 3.5 in., R-19 and R-21 at 5.5 in., and R-30 at 8 in. (ASTM C518, 75°F). They're easier to handle than fiberglass (no skin irritation). [58]

Hemp and cork round out the category. HempWool hemp batts are rated R-3.69/in (ASTM C518); cork insulation boards run about R-3.6–3.7 per inch (thermal conductivity 0.039–0.040 W/m·K) with good moisture resistance and sound absorption. Both are naturally fire-, mold-, and pest-resistant, used mainly in high-end green building projects. [59] [60]

NREL's REMDB 2024 has no price line for any of these materials, so get quotes for the product you want. [3] They're best suited for projects where environmental impact, indoor air quality, or specific building certifications (LEED, Passive House) are primary goals.


Which Type Is Best For Your Application

Application1st Choice2nd ChoiceWhy
Attic Floor (open)Blown-in celluloseBlown-in fiberglassCost-effective, fills around obstructions, easy to achieve R-49–R-60
Attic Roofline (conditioned)Open-cell spray foamClosed-cell spray foamAir seals + insulates in one step, follows rafter contours
Walls — New ConstructionFiberglass batt or mineral woolDense-pack cellulose (blown)Batts are cheapest; mineral wool adds fire + sound
Walls — RetrofitDense-pack celluloseInjection foamFills existing cavities without demolition
Basement WallsClosed-cell spray foamRigid foam (XPS/EPS) + framed wallSpray foam is air barrier and vapor retarder in one; rigid foam costs less but needs framing
Crawl Space WallsClosed-cell spray foamRigid foam boardMoisture resistance is critical in crawl spaces
Floor Over Unconditioned SpaceFiberglass batt (R-30 faced)Spray foam on floor undersideBatts are cheapest; spray foam air seals better
SoundproofingMineral woolDense-pack celluloseMineral wool absorbs sound well (NRC 1.10 for a 3 in. ROCKWOOL Safe'n'Sound batt); cellulose provides good mass
Fire SafetyMineral woolFiberglass (unfaced)Mineral wool: FSI 0, SDI 0 (ASTM E84), noncombustible (ASTM E136)
Budget / Maximum ValueFiberglass batt (DIY)Blown-in celluloseBatts cost the least in an open stud wall and loose fill the least on an attic floor
Limited Space / Max R-ValueClosed-cell spray foamPolyiso rigid boardClosed-cell foam delivers R-22 to R-26 in a 2×4 cavity

Cost rankings in this table compare NREL REMDB 2024 medians at the same R-value. [3] Closed-cell R-values in a 2×4 cavity are from the makers' ICC-ES reports, [1] [38] [6] [2] and the sound rating from ROCKWOOL's Safe'n'Sound data sheet. [32]


Cost Comparison

NREL's Residential Efficiency Measures Database (REMDB 2024) prices insulation by form and by where it goes, not by brand or fiber: one line covers all batts, fiberglass or mineral wool, and one covers loose fill, fiberglass or cellulose. [3] Common jobs side by side, professionally installed:

Form and jobR-valuePer sq ft (10th–90th percentile)1,000 sq ft, installed
Loose fill (fiberglass or cellulose), attic floor, existing homeR-49$1.02–$2.13$1,017–$2,131 (median $1,825)
Batts, attic floor, existing homeR-49$2.71–$5.11$2,712–$5,108 (median $3,372)
Batts, stud wall, new constructionR-13$1.16–$2.80$1,156–$2,800 (median $1,366)
Open-cell spray foam, stud wall, new constructionR-13$2.28–$6.11$2,285–$6,112 (median $3,977)
Closed-cell spray foam, stud wall, new constructionR-13$3.09–$9.14$3,093–$9,137 (median $4,484)
Open-cell spray foam, attic roof deck, existing homeR-21$4.09–$11.32$4,089–$11,316 (median $7,309)
Closed-cell spray foam, attic roof deck, existing homeR-29$7.80–$23.04$7,799–$23,045 (median $11,258)
EPS board, wall sheathing, new constructionR-5$0.93–$1.96$930–$1,957 (median $1,185)
XPS board, wall sheathing, new constructionR-5$1.14–$4.31$1,139–$4,305 (median $1,434)
Polyiso board, wall sheathing, new constructionR-6$1.11–$1.95$1,106–$1,947 (median $1,510)
Radiant barrier, atticn/a$0.67–$1.50$670–$1,505 (median $1,233)

Source: NREL REMDB 2024, installed cost in 2023 dollars, national; the range is the 10th to 90th percentile and the 1,000 sq ft column gives the median in parentheses. Costs are per square foot of the surface insulated. [3]

REMDB has no wall price for dense-pack cellulose, which it rates low on both sample size and fit, and no separate line for mineral wool or the natural materials above. The roof-deck rows sit at what one rafter-depth layer reaches: in the makers' ICC-ES reports, 5.5 inches of open-cell foam is R-19 to R-21, [6] [7] [61] and R-29 matches the 4.5-inch closed-cell roof deck the 2024 NAHB cost study priced. [62]

For project-specific estimates, use our insulation cost calculator or see application-specific guides: attic insulation cost, spray foam cost.


How to Choose: The 5 Factors

1. R-Value Requirements

Start with the end goal. What total R-value does your climate zone and the 2021 IECC require for the assembly you're insulating? ENERGY STAR's Recommended Home Insulation R-Values are given by climate zone. Reference our R-value chart for code requirements by zone, then work backward to select a material that achieves the target R-value in your available depth. [63] Our R-value per inch chart ranks every material by thermal performance per inch.

2. Budget

Loose fill and batts deliver the most R-value per dollar where depth is free. For a 1,500 sq ft attic floor at R-49, NREL's REMDB 2024 prices blown-in loose fill (cellulose or fiberglass) at $1,525–$3,197 (median $2,738) installed in an existing home. Its closed-cell foam line stops at R-42; at that level the same floor's median is $24,431 for closed-cell foam against $2,399 for loose fill, in 2023 dollars. [3] Spray foam makes sense in tight spaces and where air sealing is critical; in an open attic, loose fill reaches the same R-value for a fraction of the price. Check our insulation cost calculator for your own numbers.

3. Moisture Environment

Basements and crawl spaces need moisture-tolerant materials. Closed-cell spray foam (a Class II vapor retarder at about 1.5–2 in. or more), XPS, and EPS are the right choices below grade. Fiberglass absorbs water and loses R-value. ROCKWOOL describes its mineral wool as water repellent, [10] but it doesn't provide a vapor barrier. Always pair your insulation choice with an appropriate vapor barrier strategy.

4. Available Space

Unlimited depth (open attic floor): use the cheapest material — blown-in cellulose or fiberglass. Fixed cavity (existing 2×4 or 2×6 wall): you need higher R-per-inch materials to maximize performance. Extremely limited space (rim joists, thin wall assemblies): closed-cell spray foam's R-6 to R-7 per inch gives the most R-value in the least depth.

5. DIY vs. Professional

Fiberglass batts, mineral wool batts, and rigid foam boards are all DIY-installable with basic tools. Blown-in loose-fill cellulose is DIY-feasible (big box stores rent blowing machines), but getting consistent coverage and proper depth requires practice. Dense-pack cellulose and all spray foam types require professional installation — the equipment, training, and quality control are beyond what DIY delivers safely or effectively.

Pro Tip: Start with air sealing plus blown-in insulation in the attic. ENERGY STAR estimates that sealing and insulating together save an average of about 15% of heating and cooling costs (7–20% by climate zone), and it's a relatively straightforward job. Move to walls or other assemblies after that. [64] [65]

Pro Tip: One vapor retarder per assembly. Over existing faced fiberglass batts in the attic, add only unfaced batts or loose fill; the Standard Work Specifications allow only unfaced batts over existing insulation. [66]

Pro Tip: Consider using two different insulation types in the same wall. This is called a "hybrid" or "flash-and-batt" assembly — for example, 2 inches of closed-cell spray foam on the back of the sheathing (for air sealing and vapor control) topped with fiberglass batt to fill the remaining cavity. It puts the foam where air sealing and vapor control matter and fills the rest of the cavity with a material that costs less per R-value.


Common Mistakes

1. Choosing based on R-per-inch alone. A homeowner insulating an open attic doesn't need closed-cell spray foam at R-6 to R-7 per inch when about 14 inches of blown-in cellulose reaches R-49, [23] [27] and loose fill is the cheapest attic-floor option in NREL's cost database. [3] Match the material to the application — see our chart.

2. Skipping air sealing. This is the most common and most costly mistake. Insulation slows conductive heat transfer. Air sealing stops convective heat loss through gaps and penetrations. Seal the attic floor penetrations, top plates, duct boots, and recessed lights before insulating. ENERGY STAR models sealing and insulating together as a single project, saving an average of about 15% of heating and cooling costs. [64]

3. Wrong material in wet locations. Fiberglass batts in crawl spaces and basements is a recipe for mold and failure. Use closed-cell spray foam, rigid foam, or, if you must use fibrous insulation, mineral wool with proper moisture management.

4. Compressing batts around obstructions. Stuffing a fiberglass batt behind a wire or pipe instead of splitting it and fitting around the obstruction creates a void. That void has an R-value of approximately R-1 (still air in a thin gap). If 10% of a wall has voids, the whole wall loses far more than 10% of performance because heat flows preferentially through the weakest point. See our guide on what is R-value for why installation quality matters more than label R-value. [67] [68]

5. Ignoring thermal bridging. Filling wall cavities with R-21 insulation and calling the wall "R-21" ignores the 23–25% of the wall that's wood framing at about R-1.25/inch. By the parallel-path method, a 2×6 R-21 wall at 16 in. o.c. works out to about R-17.0 clear-wall (studs included), and the whole-wall figure is lower still (ORNL measures 2×6 walls about 17% below clear-wall). The point: the framing drags the assembly well below its label. If you're in CZ 4–8 (including Marine 4) and code calls for continuous insulation, that layer is what breaks the thermal bridge. Under the 2021 IECC (unchanged in 2024), a CZ 4–8 wood-frame wall can meet code with R-30 cavity, OR R-20 cavity plus R-5 continuous insulation ("ci"), OR R-13 cavity plus R-10 ci, OR R-0 plus R-20 ci. Don't skip the continuous layer. [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74]


Key Takeaways

  • Batts (fiberglass or mineral wool) are the lowest-cost way to fill an open stud wall, and loose fill (cellulose or fiberglass) the lowest-cost way to insulate an open attic floor, in NREL's REMDB 2024. [3] Fiberglass is highly sensitive to installation quality.
  • Dense-pack cellulose fills closed walls without demolition, and cellulose has high recycled newspaper content.
  • Mineral wool leads in fire resistance (FSI 0, SDI 0, noncombustible per ASTM E84/E136) and is a strong sound absorber.
  • Closed-cell spray foam delivers the highest R-per-inch (R-6.0–R-7.0) plus air sealing plus moisture control, but at R-13 in a stud wall it costs about three times what batts cost. [3]
  • Rigid foam boards (EPS, XPS, polyiso) are essential for continuous exterior insulation and below-grade applications.
  • Radiant barriers are effective supplements in hot climates (CZ 1–2, especially with attic ducts) only — they're not substitutes for conventional insulation.
  • Always pair insulation with air sealing — ENERGY STAR estimates that sealing and insulating together save an average of about 15% of heating and cooling costs (7–20% by climate zone).
  • Use our R-value chart to find the right R-value target, then pick the material that meets it for your application and budget.

FAQ

What's the best type of insulation overall?

There's no single "best": it depends entirely on the application. For open attics, blown-in cellulose or fiberglass offers the best value. For walls in new construction, fiberglass batts or mineral wool are standard. For basements and crawl spaces, closed-cell spray foam or rigid foam board. For soundproofing, mineral wool. For fire-rated assemblies, mineral wool. See the decision table above for application-specific recommendations.

What's the most cost-effective insulation?

In NREL's REMDB 2024, loose fill (blown cellulose or fiberglass) has the lowest installed cost on an open attic floor, $1.02–$2.13 per sq ft (median $1.83) at R-49 in an existing home, and batts are the lowest-cost way to fill an open stud wall, $1.16–$2.80 per sq ft (median $1.37) at R-13 in new construction (2023 dollars, national). [3] Spray foam costs more, but it air seals as it insulates, which can take the place of a separate air-sealing step. Use our insulation cost calculator for a head-to-head comparison.

Which insulation is best for soundproofing?

Mineral wool is a strong sound absorber: ROCKWOOL rates its 3-inch Safe'n'Sound batt at NRC 1.10 (ASTM C423). [32] It's a common choice for sound-rated wall assemblies (STC partitions), home theaters, and shared-wall applications. Cellulose is a solid second choice thanks to its mass. Closed-cell spray foam is one of the worst for soundproofing because its rigid structure transmits sound rather than absorbing it. Full details in our soundproofing guide.

Can I mix different types of insulation?

Yes, and in many cases you should. Common hybrid approaches include closed-cell spray foam on the sheathing side of a wall cavity topped with fiberglass batts (flash-and-batt), rigid foam over exterior sheathing with batt insulation in the cavity, and blown-in insulation on top of existing fiberglass batts in the attic. The key rule: don't trap a vapor retarder in the middle of the assembly. If you're adding insulation on top of faced batts, use loose fill or unfaced batts, as the Standard Work Specifications require for batts. [66]

What's the best insulation for DIY installation?

Fiberglass batts and mineral wool batts are the most DIY-friendly; they require only a utility knife, straight edge, and safety gear (mask, gloves, long sleeves). Rigid foam boards are also DIY-installable with a score-and-snap technique. Loose-fill cellulose in an open attic is manageable with a rental blowing machine from a home center (some retailers provide the machine free with minimum material purchase). Dense-pack cellulose and all spray foam applications should be left to professionals; the equipment requirements, safety concerns, and quality-control demands exceed typical DIY capability.

Sources

  1. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: Huntsman Building Solutions, LLC), ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-2629 (Foam-Lok FL2000 (closed-cell; aka Air Tight CC, GuardFoam 55 CC, Foam-Lok AB2000)), reissued Dec 2021, revised Jul 2022 (copy on huntsmanbuildingsolutions.com) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  2. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: Huntsman Building Solutions, LLC), ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-4073 (Heatlok HFO High Lift (closed-cell, HFO)), reissued Aug 2026 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  3. National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), National Residential Efficiency Measures Database (REMDB) 2024 — machine-readable file REMDB_2024.12.23.xlsx (CC BY 4.0) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  4. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory / US DOE Building America Solution Center, Typical R-values and Vapor Retarder Classifications for Common Insulation Materials — Building America Solution Center (PNNL for US DOE), updated 2021-12-23 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  5. Owens Corning Foam Insulation, LLC, Product Data Sheet FOAMULAR NGX 250 XPS Insulation, Pub. No. 43522-V, Oct 2025 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  6. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: SOPREMA Corporation), ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-4411 (SOPRA-SPF 201 (closed-cell)), reissued May 2021 (renewal May 2023) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  7. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: Huntsman Building Solutions LLC), ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-1826 (Classic Ultra Select (also Classic, Classic Ultra) open-cell), reissued Mar 2026 (renewal Feb 2027) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  8. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: Huntsman Building Solutions, LLC), ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-2847 (Foam-LOK FL500 (aka AirTight OC, GUARDFOAM 55 OC, Open Cell Retrofit Foam) open-cell), reissued Sep 2026 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  9. ROCKWOOL, ROCKWOOL Comfortbatt Thermal Batt Insulation Technical Data Sheet (US), issued 07-2026 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  10. ROCKWOOL, Residential Product Guide (US), May 2025 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  11. Owens Corning, PINK Next Gen Fiberglas Insulation Product Data Sheet (Pub. 10024567-J, May 2026) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  12. Owens Corning, PINK Next Gen Fiberglas Insulation Manufacturers Fact Sheet (Pub. 10025109-B, May 2026) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  13. Johns Manville, Fiberglass Manufacturers Fact Sheet (BID-380, 12/19, (c)2019) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  14. City of Seattle SDCI (adopts WA State Energy Code App. A), 2021 Seattle Energy Code, Appendix A (Default Heat Loss Coefficients), Table A101.4 R-value of fiberglass batts compressed within various depth cavities (retrieved Oct 2026)
  15. CertainTeed, High-Performance Fiber Glass Building Insulation Batts spec sheet (Code 30-21-1239, 6/01) — Fine Homebuilding-hosted copy (retrieved Oct 2026)
  16. Owens Corning, ProPink L77 PINK Fiberglas Loosefill Insulation Manufacturers Fact Sheet (Pub. 22676-O, Dec 2023) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  17. Johns Manville, JM Building Insulation Submittal Form (BID-0028, 9/26) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  18. Knauf Insulation, Knauf Jet Stream ULTRA Blowing Insulation Product Data Sheet (valid from 05/25; (c)2024), linked from knaufnorthamerica.com product page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  19. CertainTeed, CertainTeed InsulSafe SP Fiberglass Blowing Insulation data sheet (Code No. 09-11-4525-US-EN, 10/24) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  20. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Christian, Kosny, Desjarlais, Childs), The Whole Wall Thermal Performance Calculator — On the Net, Thermal Envelopes VII (1998) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  21. US Navy Civil Engineering Laboratory (contract N68305-77C-0009; work by Johns-Manville R&D Center, D. Verschoor), Effectiveness of Building Insulation Applications (Nov 1977), DTIC ADA053452 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  22. BRANZ (New Zealand building research levy-funded institute), Poorly fitted wall insulation cuts thermal performance, BUILD 117 (Apr/May 2010), I. Cox-Smith (retrieved Oct 2026)
  23. Applegate Insulation (Greenfiber), Applegate Loose-fill Cellulose Insulation Fact Sheet (#IFS-ALF26.5-201606-A, (c)2020; RDS-LF9587), archived copy (Wayback Machine 2023-05-25) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  24. Nu-Wool Co., Inc., Nu-Wool Premium Cellulose Insulation product page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  25. US Federal Trade Commission (16 CFR 460), 16 CFR Part 460 Labeling and Advertising of Home Insulation (FTC R-value Rule), via Cornell LII e-CFR mirror - § 460.5 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  26. Greenfiber, SANCTUARY Cellulose Fact Sheet (PM-6.3329 Rev K, 05/26) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  27. Nu-Wool Co., Inc., Nu-Wool 'This Is Cellulose' FTC fact sheet / Pneumatic Application Coverage Chart (05/2016) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  28. U.S. DOE Building America Solution Center (PNNL), Dense-Pack Insulation (REDCalc tool page, undated) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  29. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (Wilkes & Childs), Thermal Performance of Fiberglass and Cellulose Attic Insulations, ASHRAE/DOE/BTECC Thermal Performance of the Exterior Envelopes of Buildings V (Dec 1992) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  30. Applegate Insulation (Greenfiber), Applegate Stabilized Cellulose Insulation Fact Sheet (PM 6.3330 Rev A 09/24, Greenfiber) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  31. Owens Corning (Thermafiber), Thermafiber Fire & Sound Guard Plus Manufacturers Fact Sheet (Pub. 10027588, Oct 2024) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  32. ROCKWOOL, Safe'n'Sound Fire and Soundproofing Insulation Technical Data Sheet, issued 11-2025 (supersedes 07-2025) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  33. US Federal Trade Commission (16 CFR 460), 16 CFR Part 460 Labeling and Advertising of Home Insulation (FTC R-value Rule), via Cornell LII e-CFR mirror - § 460.20 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  34. Huntsman Building Solutions (Canada), Sealection 500 Technical Data Sheet, AN 20.00085/20.00390, REV 07.16.21 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  35. Elastochem Specialty Chemicals Inc., Insulthane 450 NM Technical Data Sheet SFM-US-COM-0004 Rev 5 (retrieved Nov 2026)
  36. ICC Evaluation Service (ICC-ES), ESR-5097 Akfix SPR 210/330/430 (Akkim Europe), reissued March 2025 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  37. U.S. DOE Building America Solution Center (PNNL), BASC (PNNL): Class I Vapor Retarders Not Installed in Above-Grade Walls in Warm-Humid Climate (updated 2018-06-06), citing IRC 2009/2012 definitions (retrieved Oct 2026)
  38. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: North American Spray Foam Polymers), ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-4484 (EPS 2000 Closed Cell Spray Foam (North American Spray Foam Polymers)), reissued Oct 2022, archived copy (Wayback Machine 2023-05-07); not in the ICC-ES directory as of Nov 2026 (retrieved Nov 2026)
  39. Rmax, Rmax Product Data Sheet THERMASHEATH (foil-faced polyiso), Revision 05-15-2025 (retrieved Nov 2026)
  40. Sika Corporation, Product Data Sheet Sarnatherm ISO, Aug 2024, v06.03 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  41. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: Alleguard), ICC-ES ESR-5261, reissued Feb 2026 (renewal Feb 2027) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  42. Owens Corning Foam Insulation, LLC, FOAMULAR & FOAMULAR NGX XPS Insulation: ASTM C578 Types and Physical Properties (Tech Bulletin, Pub. No. 10015702-C, July 2025) reproducing ASTM C578-23 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  43. Atlas Molded Products (division of Atlas Roofing Corp.), ThermalStar E Tech Data sheet (ARC-064 TS E Tech-Data_10.25) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  44. DuPont (Performance Building Solutions), Styrofoam Brand Square Edge Extruded Polystyrene Foam Insulation product page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  45. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (T. Stovall), Closed Cell Foam Insulation: A Review of Long Term Thermal Performance Research, ORNL/TM-2012/583, Nov 2012 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  46. NRCA, Professional Roofing, 'PIMA updates its QualityMark CM program for determining long-term thermal resistance', Mark S. Graham (NRCA), Professional Roofing, Aug 2013 (Tech Today) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  47. Polyisocyanurate Insulation Manufacturers Association (PIMA), PIMA Performance Bulletin #04 'Measuring the R-value of Polyiso Roof Insulation' (footer 5/14; cites 2015 data) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  48. National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA), Professional Roofing, Tech Today, Mark S. Graham, Professional Roofing, March 2015 ('NRCA tests reveal polyisocyanurate R-values are lower than product manufacturers' published long-term thermal resistance values') (retrieved Nov 2026)
  49. Building Science Corporation, Info-502: Temperature Dependence of R-values in Polyisocyanurate Roof Insulation (effective 2013-04-12) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  50. Government of Alberta, Infrastructure Technical Services Branch, Design & Technology Series 06: Understanding Insulation — Considerations for PERSIST Assemblies (c. 2016) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  51. National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA), Professional Roofing, Tech Today, Mark S. Graham, Professional Roofing, June 2016 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  52. Federal Trade Commission (eCFR), 16 CFR Part 460 (FTC R-value Rule), eCFR up to date as of 10/08/2026 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  53. ASTM International, ASTM C1313/C1313M-13 Standard Specification for Sheet Radiant Barriers — store abstract page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  54. Oak Ridge National Laboratory, ORNL Radiant Barrier Fact Sheet — appendix tables page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  55. U.S. DOE Building America (PNNL), Building America Energy Performance Brief: Installing a Radiant Barrier in the Attic (PNNL-SA-83945, Oct 2011) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  56. Florida Solar Energy Center (UCF), FSEC-EN-15 'Radiant Barriers: A Question and Answer Primer' (I. Melody; rev. P. Fairey, D. Beal; ©2005) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  57. Havelock Wool, Havelock Wool Data Sheet (undated; served from Havelock's Shopify CDN) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  58. Bonded Logic, Inc. (Chandler, AZ), UltraTouch Denim Insulation product data sheet (undated; hosted on Home Depot CDN) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  59. Hempitecture, Hempitecture Product Guide (2025; uploaded 2025/04) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  60. Amorim Cork Solutions, Expanded insulation corkboard — Material Data Sheet (CTP-465/002, May 2026, EN) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  61. ICC Evaluation Service (holder: Universal Polymers Corporation), ICC-ES Evaluation Report ESR-3803 (UPC 500 half-pound open-cell SPF), reissued May 2022, archived copy (Wayback Machine 2023-05-07); not in the ICC-ES directory as of Nov 2026 (retrieved Nov 2026)
  62. Home Innovation Research Labs (NAHB subsidiary), prepared for NAHB, 2024 IECC Cost Analysis for Single-Family Homes, Report CR1729.2.01132025 (Jan 13, 2025) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  63. US EPA ENERGY STAR, ENERGY STAR (US EPA) 'Recommended Home Insulation R-Values' - Recommended insulation levels for retrofitting existing wood-framed buildings (retrieved Oct 2026)
  64. US EPA ENERGY STAR, ENERGY STAR 'Methodology for Estimated Energy Savings' (retrieved Oct 2026)
  65. U.S. EPA ENERGY STAR, ENERGY STAR Seal and Insulate page (retrieved Oct 2026)
  66. National Laboratory of the Rockies (NLR, formerly NREL) for the U.S. Department of Energy, Standard Work Specifications, Detail 4.0103.3: Accessible Attic - Batt Insulation Over Existing Insulation (web page) (retrieved Nov 2026)
  67. City of Seattle SDCI (Seattle Energy Code, derived from Washington State Energy Code), 2018 Seattle Energy Code, Appendix A Default Heat Loss Coefficients, Sec. A101.3 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  68. City of Saskatoon Building Standards (reproducing NRC National Building Code of Canada 2015), City of Saskatoon Energy Efficiency Handbook (printed July 2019), reproducing NBC 2015 Table A-9.36.2.4.(1)-D (retrieved Nov 2026)
  69. ASHRAE / ANSI / IES, ANSI/ASHRAE/IES Addendum ay to Standard 90.1-2022 (approved 2024-10-31), Normative Appendix A sec. A3.4.1 (retrieved Oct 2026)
  70. Natural Resources Canada (Government of Canada), NRCan, Tables for Calculating Effective Thermal Resistance of Opaque Assemblies (ENERGY STAR for New Homes; issued 2014-01-02, modified 2025-01-14) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  71. City of Owatonna, MN Building Department, City of Owatonna (MN) Building Department: Characteristics of Building Materials (Jan 28, 2009) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  72. California Energy Commission (code text) via Energy Code Ace, California 2013 Title 24 Part 6 Joint Appendix JA4.6 'Physical Properties of Materials' (Table 4.6.1), hosted by Energy Code Ace (CA utility program) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  73. Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Christian, Kosny, Desjarlais, Childs (ORNL): 'The Whole-Wall Thermal Performance Calculator—On the Net' (Thermal Envelopes VII, c.1998) (retrieved Oct 2026)
  74. International Code Council (ICC), 2021 IECC Errata (complete) - Table R402.1.3 entry, Printings: All, posted 2021-08-10 updated 2026-09-18 (retrieved Oct 2026)